Season Predictions: Mid-season review

The Premier League is now over halfway through the season’s fixtures, and there is plenty to dwell on from the last few months of football. Back in August, the iThinkUnited season predictions were published on the blog. Now at the halfway stage of 2012-2013, here’s a look at whether those predictions are coming true, or whether they need revising:

Cup Winners

COMMUNITY SHIELD:

August prediction: Manchester City

City did indeed win the community shield over ten-man Chelsea as a show of intent for the coming season.

Mid-season prediction: Won by Manchester City

CARLING CUP:

August prediction: Manchester United

United unluckily fell to Chelsea in the fourth round, who now themselves look like the favourites for the trophy.

Mid-season prediction: Chelsea

FA CUP:

August prediction: Liverpool

Liverpool’s defence, and in particular their goalkeeper, haven’t looked as solid as last season, but perhaps in the new year (with a few astute signings) the Merseysiders will go on a successful cup run.

Mid-season prediction: Liverpool

CHAMPIONS LEAGUE:

August prediction: Real Madrid

Madrid may be behind Barcelona in La Liga, but have qualified with relative ease from a tough Champions League group, and under Mourinho still would be most people’s favourites. A certain team in red lie eagerly in waiting first however.

Mid-season prediction: Real Madrid

Premier League

CHAMPIONS:

August prediction: Manchester United

Manchester United has opened-up an impressive lead at the top of the table, and if they can avoid another plague of injuries there’s no reason they shouldn’t be lifting the title come May.

Mid-season prediction: Manchester United

TOP FOUR:

August prediction: 2-City, 3-Arsenal, 4-Chelsea

It would be odd if Manchester City failed to finish in the top two after last season’s triumph, despite a recent Chelsea resurgence. The other spots are up for grabs between Chelsea, Arsenal, Tottenham and even Everton. A typical late Arsenal surge may just pip the others to third.

Mid-season prediction: 2-City, 3-Arsenal, 4-Chelsea

RELEGATED:
August prediction: Southampton, Aston Villa, Reading

Accepting that Sunderland and Newcastle are probably too strong to get relegated, it appears a five horse race between QPR, Reading, Wigan, Southampton and Aston Villa. Wigan always seem to get themselves out of trouble, and a team spirit that seems to abide at Reading may be the key factor that saves them come May.

Mid-season prediction: Southampton, Aston Villa, QPR

PLAYER OF THE YEAR:

August prediction: Nani

Whilst you can’t doubt Nani had the potential to be player of the season, he couldn’t be further away from it. By far the worst prediction of the lot, Nani has had a torrid season so far. Meanwhile it is the likes of Gareth Bale, Juan Mata, and Robin van Persie who appear to vying for the award.

Mid-season prediction: Gareth Bale

TOP SCORER:

August prediction: Wayne Rooney

An early injury and the acquisition of van Persie to United makes this prediction look increasingly unlikely. Perhaps it will turn out to be the Dutchman who scores the most goals.

Mid-season prediction: Robin van Persie

Other Predictions

BEST SIGNING:

August prediction: Eden Hazard

Hazard has indeed looked a quality signing so far for Chelsea. Santi Cazorla, Robin van Persie and Moussa Dembele have also looked like superb purchases for their respective clubs. Michu at a bargain £2million for Swansea City looks by far the most effective and financially-astute purchase of the season however.

Mid-season prediction: Michu

SURPRISE TEAM:

August prediction: Fulham

Players at Fulham such as Dimitar Berbatov have helped to install some quality into the team, although the departures of Moussa Dembele and Clint Dempsey are obviously a setback for the side. A recent blip has seen Fulham ‘fall faster than Felix Baumgartner’ in the table as one football presenter put it. Nevertheless, come the end of the season it is still possible Fulham may surprise us all with a good top half of the table finish.

Mid-season prediction: Fulham

FLOP TEAM:

August prediction: Newcastle

To call Newcastle a flop may seem harsh, but they are evidently not going to finish anywhere near their 5^th place from last season. A second-half of the table finish, as they are currently placed, would be an obvious disappointment.

Mid-season prediction: Newcastle

Analysis: Manchester United 2 West Bromwich Albion 0

Premier League, Saturday 29^th December 2012

Manchester United picked up another three points with a relatively undramatic victory over West Bromwich Albion. An early own goal set United on their way, before a tentative second half culminated in a late Robin van Persie strike to seal the victory. Here’s the analysis:

Defensive solidity and tactics

This was only a fifth clean sheet of the season for United, and Nemanja Vidic was largely to thank. The Serbian won tackles, headers, and made clearances and interceptions as he looked right on top of his game. Despite this however, perhaps because of Vidic’s diminishing pace, United defended very deep and this invited second half pressure from West Brom. Nevertheless, Vidic and the rest of United’s defence did a good enough job to prevent any concessions.

Late in the second half, Sir Alex Ferguson switched his back four to a back five. Chris Smalling moved into the centre and Antonio Valencia moved to right wing-back as United converted to a 5-4-1. This move ensured the Reds three central defenders nullified any West Brom threat and gave license to the full-backs to push on in the counter-attack which helped to pin the Baggies back. It was an astute, late tactical switch from Ferguson.

A midfield axis

Michael Carrick and Tom Cleverley lined-up alongside the returning Shinji Kagawa to create a midfield axis many have been longing to see. Cleverley and Kagawa in particular work well together. Cleverley likes to push forward and find space, and his one-touch passing is often in tandem with the Japanese. Cleverley’s forward-thinking also ensures Kagawa doesn’t become isolated, as he can do if for example Scholes and Carrick play behind him and sit too deep.

Amidst terrible conditions, this midfield trio tired and inevitably lost some of their stranglehold of the game after they dominated the first half. Cleverley and Kagawa made way for Scholes and van Persie, who each brought a calm and control to United late in the match, as well as a fresh energy, and saw out the victory.

Going Forward

A clean sheet and good defensive performance were no doubt the main positives from this match for Manchester United. The midfield trio of Carrick, Cleverley and Kagawa was encouraging, and van Persie once again showed his class when he came on. Seven points out of nine for the festive period is a good return so far, and should United make it ten out of twelve after an encounter with Wigan, then they will be flying very high indeed.

Ratings

[4-2-3-1]: De Gea-6, Smalling-6, Vidic-8*, Evans-7, Evra-7, Valencia-6, Carrick-7, Cleverley-7, Young-7, Kagawa-7, Welbeck-6

(Scholes-6, van Persie-7)

*Man of the match

Mid-Season Review

19 games into the Premier League campaign, and Manchester United find themselves sitting pretty on top of the table. Despite a disappointing Capital One Cup exit, the Red Devils are into the last 16 of the Champions League awaiting a mouth-watering clash with Real Madrid. Now is the time to take stock, and review Manchester United’s season so far.

The story of United’s season has been defensive calamities combined with attacking excellence. The Reds have scored goals at a fantastic rate, but have needed to because of the uncharacteristic rate of conceding. United have already let in more goals than in any of their entire title-winning seasons in recent years.

If Sir Alex Ferguson’s team can go on and keep winning games however, then this will be seen as a great season. United are in a great position to regain the title, and will be looking to go far in the FA Cup and Champions League.

Below are the mid-season awards:

Players

BEST PLAYER:

Wayne Rooney

This may seem odd to some, but Wayne Rooney is certainly up there. A dreadful start against Everton, and a dreadful recent performance against Swansea have been but the rare lowpoints of an impressive campaign. The iThinkUnited player ratings system ranks Rooney as the most impressive player this season, and superb performances against Tottenham and Manchester City are among his highlights. Robin van Persie and Rafael are not far behind.

WORST PLAYER:

Nani

Like Rooney, Nani started this season dreadfully against Everton, and simply hasn’t recovered. Rumours of injury and dissent are common when the Portuguese is mentioned, and Nani simply isn’t having a good season at all.

BEST TEAM:

De Gea, Rafael, Ferdinand, Evans, Evra, Carrick, Cleverley, Anderson, Rooney, van Persie, Hernandez

According to the iThinkUnited player ratings system, this eleven has been United’s best this season.

Matches

BEST MATCH:

Manchester City 2 Manchester United 3

Manchester United have been part of some extraordinary matches this season, but the Manchester derby has to be the highlight. Though torture to some, the dramatic victory over United’s cross-city rivals will be hard to beat for entertainment.

WORST MATCH:

Manchester United 0 CFR Cluj 1

In the context of the season, United have performed worse than this game, but if you had to miss one United game this year, it would be this. A dead-rubber as far as United were concerned, they never got going, and eventually lost to the Romanians. As boring as they come.

Goals

BEST GOAL SCORED:

Robin van Persie vs Fulham

Van Persie’s first goal in a United shirt was excellent. He hooked a volley into the corner from a difficult angle, and thus started his flourishing Manchester United career. Tom Cleverley is a close contender with some excellent goals against Newcastle and Sunderland.

WORST GOAL CONCEDED:

Adam le Fondre for Reading

There are unfortunately many contenders for this award, but after weeks of lessons not learnt, calamitous defending at the Madejski stadium was hard to believe.

Moments

MOST ENTHRALLING MOMENT:

Robin van Persie vs Manchester City

The late goal that won the Manchester derby has to be the most enthralling moment of the season so far. Late winners against Southampton, Aston Villa and Newcastle aren’t far behind however.

MOST DISAPPOINTING MOMENT:

The first half against Tottenham

After a shocking performance against Liverpool the week before, lessons were not learned as United were beaten in the first half against Tottenham. Ryan Giggs and Paul Scholes started, and were exposed. Giggs’ substitution for Rooney at half-time highlighted the ineffectiveness of United’s old guard, and it was a sad sight. Thankfully Giggs had improved his form since then.

BEST MISCALLENOUS MOMENT:

Darren Fletcher’s return

It was feared the Scot would never return to the first-team football after he was diagnosed with illness, so when he made his comeback as a substitute against Galatasaray it was a truly magnificent moment. His goal against QPR on his Premier League comeback was also special.

Analysis: Manchester United 4 Newcastle United 3

Premier League, Wednesday 26^th December 2012

This match was pure drama, but most importantly a match where Manchester United picked up three points and extended their lead at the top of the table to seven points. Newcastle lead three times, but each time were pegged back with goals from Jonny Evans, Patrice Evra and Robin van Persie, before Javier Hernandez stuck an injury time winner. Here’s some thoughts from the game:

Van Persie: the all-rounder

Robin van Persie showed all his remarkable qualities against Newcastle as he helped the Reds to secure a win. He delivered dangerous set-pieces, and of course struck an important goal, but most notably in this game was his impressive hold-up play. The Dutchman is proving to be one of the best around at holding the ball up and bringing others into play, an essential trait. It allows the team to regain possession and regain their shape as they look to attack teams.

In the last twenty minutes of this match, van Persie dropped slightly deeper behind Javier Hernandez. His hold-up play in this area of the pitch was superb, and he brought width to the play. With Carrick sitting deeper as a playmaker and defensive midfielder, and Cleverley adding energy and quick-thinking, this tactical switch is possibly what won Manchester United the game, and van Persie must take a lot of credit for his part.

Mistakes

The first-half was littered with individual errors from the Reds. Each goal can be attributed to errors, and these must be cut out if Sir Alex Ferguson’s side are to stop conceding. The pitch and the conditions were not in any way helpful, but it did not excuse some of the poor play.

Patrice Evra in particular can be singled out for his lacklustre attempt to close-down the ball leading to Newcastle’s second goal. Rio Ferdinand was rightly apoplectic with the Frenchman, who seemed to switch off before eventually jogging towards his opposition man. Whilst enormously effective and underrated in Manchester United’s attack, Evra appears susceptible to a lack of concentration in defence, something that could cost the Reds further.

Going Forward

This game once again showed the courage and resilience of an extraordinary Manchester United team. Halfway through the season now, they are on course for 92 points. There were some shoddy performances in this game, but the three points was the most important thing. A rotated team will now look to beat West Brom at home to consolidate the lead at the top of the table.

Ratings

[4-4-1-1]: De Gea-5, Smalling-5, Ferdinand-6, Evans-5, Evra-6 Valencia-6, Carrick-7, Scholes-6, Giggs-7, van Persie-7*, Hernandez-7

(Cleverley-7, Fletcher-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Swansea City 1 Manchester United 1

Premier League, Sunday 23^rd December 2012

Manchester United’s first draw of the season came after a hard-fought battle at the Liberty Stadium. Patrice Evra’s opener was cancelled out by the prolific Michu. United then failed to capitalise on second half domination as Swansea worked hard to defend their goal. Here are some talking points from the game:

Rooney pivotal

Wayne Rooney had a bad game against Swansea, and this certainly impacted on the scoreline. When at his best, Rooney inspires United to be at their best; he is the pivot of the team. Against Swansea however, Rooney was poor, and United struggled to find a second goal as a result of that.

The Swansea defence marked Rooney exceptionally well throughout the game, limiting his influence for the most part. Nevertheless, the passes Rooney did make were often wayward. It was no surprise when he was substituted late on. Despite excellent peformances from Michael Carrick behind him, and Robin van Persie in front of him, Rooney’s lacklustre display meant United couldn’t quite find the extra gear that would’ve got them the three points in Wales.

Corners

After failing to register a single goal from a corner last season, United have now scored several this season. The reasons for this appear to be multiple. Firstly, the delivery from summer signing van Persie, and the improved Wayne Rooney, have offered more dangerous set-pieces that at most times last season. Secondly, it would be no surprise had United not worked on their set-pieces in training in order to get more success from them; it seems to have worked.

Patrice Evra scored from a corner against Swansea, and his recent goal-scoring glut (already three this season) has been as a result of his presence at set-pieces. Evra would previously stay back and defend when United were attacking set-pieces, mainly due to his height. This year however, the Frenchman has been going up for corners, and his unlikely ability to jump and head, combined with an underestimation from the opposition, has contributed to him scoring more.

 Going Forward

Ten points from twelve over the festive period would be an excellent return for United. After dropping two against Swansea, the onus is now on to win the other three. A point at the Liberty Stadium is not a bad result, but the disappointing manner of the performance will have left Sir Alex Ferguson frustrated. Utilising the squad will now be the name of the game as United look to pick up full points from the following games.

Ratings

[4-4-2]: De Gea-6, Jones-6, Vidic-6, Evans-6, Evra-6 Valencia-6, Carrick-8*, Cleverley-6, Young-6, Rooney-5, van Persie-7

(Hernandez-6, Giggs-7, Scholes-6)

*Man of the match

Ronaldo and Rooney: Variance in the best

Cristiano Ronaldo and Wayne Rooney are two of the most well-known football players in the world, at the two of the most well-known clubs. And when Real Madrid and Manchester United meet in their titanic Champions League encounter in February, these two footballing superstars may well be the decisive factors in determining its outcome.

Ronaldo and Rooney are not carbon-copies of each other. Both are imposing attacking players, both influence games where others struggle, but both have their own identities, their own playing styles. It was the combination of these attacking identities that propelled United to soar at dizzy heights during the late noughties.

Whilst both are capable of that game-changing moment (think Rooney vs. City, or any Ronaldo free-kick), the sudden exhibition of technical brilliance is certainly more frequently observed when watching the Portuguese. The 27 year old is insatiable in his desire for excellence, and from that comes his staggering, unstoppable goal return. Give Ronaldo the ball and he will run at you. He strikes fear in the opposition that he attacks. And stand off him at your peril, that 30 yard screamer is ready to be unleashed.

Rooney meanwhile has become a crucial clog in the Manchester United machine. He may be less impactful than his Portuguese counterpart, but he is no less resourceful. His work-rate embodies the team ethic of the club, and his technical attributes have improved vastly during his time there.

The Englishman has gone from raw talent to matured artist. His passing is reminiscent of his elder teammate, Paul Scholes. His goal return is ever-increasing, largely due to his improved timing and positional sense. Rooney’s importance to the Manchester United team is underrated and often unnoticed, yet essential.

What Ronaldo and Rooney share are their pivotal roles in their respective sides. They are chief tormenters; Ronaldo the impulsive game-changer and Rooney the instrumental aggressor. Both are distinct, both are integral.

Should Ronaldo be on top of his game when Madrid faces United, then the team in Red will come up against an unstoppable phenomenon. Should Rooney be at his best, then United’s potential will be unleashed.

Ronaldo is so good that his brilliance is almost independent of his team, an outside force that thrusts Madrid to triumph. Rooney is so good that his brilliance is an ingrained part of Manchester United. Without him, United miss their fulcrum.

It may be the variance in these two great players that defines the outcome of the upcoming Champions League tie. If Ronaldo is off his game, then Madrid may still be able to work a result. If Rooney is off his game, then United will face a near impossible task. If both players are at their best, this tie will live up to its huge billing: the world’s most colossal clubs, featuring the world’s best players.

What can be said with certainty is that these players will earn their place in football’s hall of fame. Ronaldo; technically supreme, a force of power and skill, and Rooney; a matured controller, a footballing genius: variance in two of the world’s best.

Analysis: Manchester United 3 Sunderland 1

Premier League, Saturday 15^th December 2012

This was a mostly comfortable performance for Manchester United, albeit with some caveats. The first-half was sublime, and United rode on that excellence for the rest of the game. The goals came from van Persie, Cleverley, and Rooney, but it was a cheap concession and further misses that will have irked Sir Alex Ferguson. Here’s the analysis:

Midfield maestros

Michael Carrick and Tom Cleverley started in midfield for the second time in a row after their magnificent performance at Eastlands. The two have started together in United’s most impressive wins so far this season (Man City, Chelsea, Arsenal, Newcastle), and once again proved their worth against Sunderland.

Carrick was dominant. He was as usual positionally excellent, and supreme on the ball. He broke up play and moved the ball on quickly, striding around the pitch in his elegant fashion. His superb first-time assist for Tom Cleverley’s goal was typical of his diplay. Cleverley himself played his usual busy, quick-thinking game. The two barely gave Sunderland an inch as they worked in tandem winning the ball, passing it on speedily, and giving a platform to the attackers. Only after Paul Scholes’ introduction for Michael Carrick at half-time did United’s midfield begin to lack authority and slow down the play.

Competition in defence with young Englishmen

United’s two notable performances in defence were from the English youngsters that have missed most of the season so far: Phil Jones and Chris Smalling. Smalling was again a rock, winning everything in the air. It was Smalling’s brief lapse of concentration that contributed to Sunderland’s goal, but other than that the 23 year old was impenetrable.

Jones meanwhile at right-back was a bombarding presence who combined useful attacking instinct with authoritarian defending. The young Englishman looked back to his best at the start of the 2011/2012 season, and will only contribute to the selection headache Ferguson now faces with such an enormous squad. Jones and Smalling both will surely have big parts to play in the second half of the season.

Going Forward

An encouraging performance to build upon the magnificent win over Manchester City was needed, and that's what Manchester United gave. The Reds will now be top at Christmas, and 10 points from the 12 available up until New Year will give United a wonderfully positioned platform going into 2013.

Ratings

[4-4-2]: De Gea-7, Jones-8, Ferdinand-6, Smalling-7, Evra-6 Valencia-6, Carrick-8*, Cleverley-8, Young-8, Rooney-7, van Persie-8

(Scholes-6, Vidic-6, Giggs-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Manchester City 2 Manchester United 3

Premier League, Sunday 9th December 2012

The battle of Manchester resulted in a 3-2 win for United, and it certainly made its mark on the outcome of this season’s war. The Reds now have a six point gap at the top of the table after a victory that came from Rooney and van Persie goals. Here’s some brief analysis on the fixture:

Intensity

There was a fire about United that dragged them to this victory. When talking about intensity, United’s midfield is often condemned as lacking energy and dynamism. This intensity against City was more than midfield mobility however. It was a hunger in every player, a desire to fight for every ball combined with a rigorous passion to concentrate on the task at hand.
The intensity in this game was typified by Danny Welbeck’s late ball-winning challenge that led to van Persie’s goal-scoring free-kick. The young Englishman showed a disciplined longing to win the ball for his side which paid dividends.
This winning intensity has been absent in many United performances this season in which the Reds have conceded goals and looked bereft of enthusiasm. It also was the same intensity however that has brought United back from the brink on many occasions; a delightful passion.

Counter attack

Tactically, Sir Alex Ferguson was rewarded for bravery and intelligence. The 4-4-1-1 counter-attacked brilliantly against City, with every role playing its part well. The back four were purposeful and superior in their defending, with the full-backs contributing significantly to attack. The wide positions were sources of joy for United, and Young and Valencia did well to stretch City. Michael Carrick and Tom Cleverley in midfield were quick-witted and clever in their play, Rooney was dangerous in a forward role, and van Persie was sublime in linking the play and holding up the ball.
The set-up had flaws. United’s attacking full-backs left gaps which City exposed to good effect in the second-half. The Reds were however saved from being punished more in these positions due to excellent one-on-one defender from the centre-backs.

Going Forward

This was a fantastic team-performance from United. Each player played his part superbly, eventually culminating in a well-earned three points, and defeat of their closest rivals. This big match performance will not be repeated every week, but was a reminder of United’s capabilities. Sitting pretty at the top of the table, Sir Alex Ferguson, the team, and the fans, will be relishing the challenges that lie ahead.

Ratings

[4-4-1-1]: De Gea-8, Rafael-8, Ferdinand-8, Evans-8, Evra-7, Valencia-6, Carrick-8, Cleverley-7, Young-8, Rooney-9*, van Persie-8
(Smalling-8, Jones-6, Welbeck-7)
*Man of the match

Analysis: Manchester United 0 CFR Cluj 1

Champions League, Wednesday 5^th December 2012

This was a somewhat dull fixture which meant a great deal to Cluj but little to United. A second-half screamer ensured the win for the Romanians, despite the fact they eventually failed to progress from the group stage. Here are some brief talking points from the game:

Defensive options

The back line of Jones, Smalling, Wootton, and Büttner was a complete change from the regular back four this season, and gave us a glimpse of United’s back-up options in that area. Jones was impressive, galloping back and forth and putting in some good crosses. Smalling was dominant in the air and strong in the tackle, but once again showed his frailties with the ball at his feet. Wootton was exposed at times, and further emphasised that his future may lay away from Old Trafford. Büttner was lively, and rash, but a good threat going forward.

Rooney on the right

Wayne Rooney started on the right for the second consecutive game against Cluj. Ferguson recently hinted that Rooney needed to play continuously to keep his fitness and sharpness up, and his further deployment on the right suggests a start there in future games. With several of United’s wide options out injured, there appears to be some sense in this selection.

Rooney’s delivery has greatly increased over recent months, making his crossing potential much greater from the right. His link-up play with Phil Jones down that side against Cluj was also impressive, and that can no doubt be transferred to playing with Rafael. Although not at his best, the Rooney against Cluj was clearly lacking enthusiasm for a meaningless tie, and the potential to improve on that right-hand side in more important matches is evident. He has the raw tools to play there well after all.

Going Forward

This game is unlikely to have had any positive impact on the squad ahead of the Manchester derby this weekend. It was a disappointment to lose at home, albeit in an unimportant fixture. Many of the players lacked the enthusiasm to perform to their highest level, and this showed. No doubt there will be a greater intensity about United in the bigger games to come.

Ratings

De Gea-6, Jones-7*, Smalling-6, Wootton-5, Büttner-6, Rooney-6, Cleverley-6, Giggs-6, Powell-6, Welbeck-7, Hernandez-6

(Scholes-6, Fletcher-6, Macheda-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Reading 3 Manchester United 4

Premier League, Saturday 1^st December 2012

34 minutes and 7 goals at the Madejski stadium eventually culminated in a tumultuous win for Manchester United over Reading. Anderson and Wayne Rooney initially overturned a one goal deficit, before Rooney and Robin van Persie had to score again to ensure the win. Below are some talking points from the match:

Defensive frailties

Beyond anything else so far this season, this was United’s worst defensive display. Three early crosses resulted in three goals for Reading, with the United defence non-existent. In fact, Jonny Evans’ positioning and decision-making was largely at fault for the goals in his direst performance for a season and a half. Anders Lindegaard, whilst not as bad as some suggested, was nevertheless apparently bereft of communication and appeared to lack command of his area in a nonchalant performance.

Half an hour in, a yellow card for Rafael was the cue for Ferguson to bring on Chris Smalling in his place to bring more height and security to the United defence. Smalling effectively nullified his side of Reading’s attack and gave more solidity when facing high balls. Rio Ferdinand had a relatively good game and was rightly nonplussed at the calamity around him. The moment of the half was when Evans and Lindegaard got mixed up dealing with a ball into the box, and Ferdinand stood there, hands on hips, as if to say “what on earth is this?.” It was a truly horrendous defensive performance from United that Sir Alex Ferguson has accepted must not happen again, and it is hard to imagine that anything as bad will happen again this season.

Another forward set-up

Another forward combination was implemented for this game against Reading, and it was one that brought goals. Wayne Rooney started on the right, Ashley Young on the left, and Anderson behind Robin van Persie up front. Rooney had an excellent game, tracking back well and using the ball wisely in forward positions. His interchangability with Young and Anderson served to cause an unstable Reading defence problems. One goal in particular was a result of Young and Rooney swapping flanks and Reading failing to track the players.

Young had one of his better games this season on the left, but this was largely due to the space he was afforded and the willing running of Patrice Evra down his side. There were still some notably awry crosses and shots from the English winger. Anderson was purposeful before being withdrawn due to injury, and van Persie was dangerous at times, albeit dropping too deep as the lone striker at times too.

This 4-2-3-1 combination worked well for the most part for United, with Wayne Rooney particularly impressing. This is a set-up that appears to favour the likes of Anderson and Shinji Kagawa, making it a contender to feature more often this season. In particular against a fragile Reading defence, United looked dangerous at nearly every attack.

Going Forward

Defensively, this was a horror show, and will surely not be repeated. It can be expected that David de Gea will come in for Anders Lindegaard in goal for the next few games. After a dead-rubber in the Champions League, United visit current champions Manchester City for the tie of the season so far in the league. United will need an improved performance, no doubt, but one can be invariably expected.

Ratings

[4-2-3-1]: Lindegaard-5, Rafael-5, Ferdinand-7, Evans-4, Evra-6, Carrick-7, Fletcher-6, Anderson-7, Young-6, Rooney-8*, van Persie-6

(Smalling-7, Jones-6, Welbeck-6)

*Man of the match

High-Speed United

In the summer of 2012, whilst many were indulging in the sportsfest of the Olympics and the European Championships, only one thing will have been on Sir Alex Ferguson’s mind: how to wrestle the title back onto the right side of Manchester. As he plotted and schemed, his mind may have well been cast back to the last time the Olympics and European Championships came round.

That time, in 2008, United fans were looking back on a famous double characterized by fast, attacking football. As Dimitar Berbatov’s agent intimated some months ago, Ferguson is looking to add more speed to the game. Perhaps a throwback to 2008 is exactly what Fergie is after.

The team of 2008 was an array of attacking talent characterised by energy, organisation, and an elegant fluidity. The front four, most often comprised of Giggs, Ronaldo, Rooney and Tevez, would cause havoc for opposition defences by swapping positions, drifting inside, drifting outside and running at players. The defence was the rock solid foundation upon which the team was built, and the midfield was the source of transition from defence to attack; the workers, the hub of the team.

The main criticism of this side was the lack of a number 9 striker, someone who would maintain their goal-orientated position and finish the many chances created by this attacking talent, whilst removing some of the goalscoring burden off Cristiano Ronaldo. So Ferguson moved to address this. He signed the classy Dimitar Berbatov, as well as giving Wayne Rooney more of an out and out striker’s role.

In the meantime Ronaldo and Tevez left the club. A more formulaic method of slowing building the play to culminate in goals brought further trophies to Old Trafford, but never the same adventure of the previous years. The thoughtful approach of a playmaking Scholes and Carrick with goal-focused strikers would never match the excitement of the dynamic years prior. It also meant more predictability. Pleasure and enthusiasm are requirements at Manchester United, and perhaps a return to the exhilaration of 2008 would give that.

Brief glimpses of a high-speed United were on display last season. The front four of Nani, Young, Rooney and Welbeck were the new Giggs, Ronaldo, Rooney and Tevez. Meanwhile, Tom Cleverley and Anderson in midfield both added a thrust and forward drive to the team that has been missing in the absences of the Brazilian and Darren Fletcher through injury, and the now-departed Owen Hargreaves.

This season has seen the introduction of Robin van Persie and Shinji Kagawa, very much forward-thinking players who play with a speed and awareness only rivalled by the very best. The rejuvenation of Javier Hernandez has been a revelation as he terrorizes defences with his movement and instinct, whilst the swashbuckling enterprises of Patrice Evra and Rafael at full-back have added more suave to the United attack.

A more energetic style may be the natural progression at Old Trafford as dynamic youngsters make their names known too. The likes of Tom Cleverley, Danny Welbeck, Phil Jones, Nick Powell and Rafael are the bedrock of the years ahead, and possess innate liveliness and zest.

United at times are still pragmatic and stale, but show all the potential of being a potent force. Performances this season have been docile, only at times for United to majestically awake from their slumber and cut down the opposition, before returning to a state of drowsiness. All the ingredients are there however for United to be firing on all cylinders when the time comes. Speed may well be the name of the game if United are to snatch back their most desired trophies this season.

Analysis: Manchester United 1 West Ham United 0

Premier League, Wednesday 28^th November 2012

This win over West Ham was rare; it was Manchester United’s first clean sheet since the 7^th October. A goal inside the first minute from Robin van Persie won the game, but only thanks to a sublime defensive display amidst disjointed attacking. Here’s some analysis on the match:

Defensive diamond

United lined up in the ‘diamond’ formation (4-3-1-2), mainly due to the number of in-form central midfielders and out-of-form/injured wingers. This formation was used the last time United kept a clean sheet in a league, and there is no coincidence its return coincided with another shutout. The big positive of the setup is its potency in midfield, and the protection this gives to the defence.

Against teams like West Ham, who setup very defensively at Old Trafford, the narrow diamond formation can struggle to break them down because of its lack of rigid width. United did well to get an early goal though, and from that point in the setup enabled defensive solidity. Michael Carrick sat in front of the back four to good effect, while Tom Cleverley, Anderson and Wayne Rooney all did their bit in tracking back and shutting the opposition midfield. The diamond may well prove an effective defensive setup away from home against the ‘bigger’ teams.

Young blood

Rafael da Silva, Chris Smalling, and Jonny Evans all started in a relatively youthful United back four, and were the stars of the show. Rafael kept Matt Jarvis in his pocket all evening with brave and clever defending, combining it with his usual attacking presence. Smalling proved his prowess in the air, something that is essential against opposition who pump forward a lot of high balls. Evans meanwhile continued to show his quickening development with a confident and assured display. Evan’s ability to break forward with poise from defence adds a welcome dimension to the attack. Along with Phil Jones, these players are proving themselves as a future bedrock of United, and are more than deserving of their current selections.

Going Forward

This performance was typical of any champions; grinding out small wins are part and parcel of winning any league. A long overdue clean sheet was promising, largely due to the solid performances of the back four. United midfielders Anderson and Carrick also had vibrant games. The anticipated return of Antonio Valencia from injury is now vital as United begin a busy winter period of games where all options are needed.

Ratings

[4-3-1-2]: Lindegaard-8, Rafael-8*, Smalling-8, Evans-8, Evra-6, Carrick-7, Anderson-7, Cleverley-6, Rooney-6, Hernandez-6, van Persie-6

(Young-6, Welbeck-6, Jones-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Manchester 3 Queens Park Rangers 1

Premier League, Saturday 24^th November 2012

Jonny Evans, Darren Fletcher, and Javier Hernandez were this week’s saviours as United once again completed a second-half comeback to beat QPR and return to the top of the table. An insipid performance contained an inspired 10 minutes in which United did their damage, and it turned out to be enough against a struggling QPR team. Here’s some thoughts from the game:

The edge of games

Being no psychological expert, this is merely a supposition, but it appears that United almost require to be on the edge of matches in order to perform this season. Sir Alex Ferguson once said of Wayne Rooney that he ‘needs to be on the edge of games’ to play well. It seems that this belief may have transferred to the whole United team. On numerous occasions this season United have looked comfortable in possession, but underwhelming in creation and excitement, and only when going behind in matches have come to life. The few matches that United have started with intensity have often been the ‘bigger’ games, for example against Chelsea, Arsenal and Newcastle.

It could possibly be that United are simply lacking the psychological intensity at the start of matches to be at their full throttle best. When other teams play United they are often lesser in ability, and therefore playing the Red Devils is one of their bigger matches meaning they have a higher intensity level. United often fail to match this level until the need for goals (i.e. going behind) is at its greatest point.

Maybe this is simply a false theory. Or maybe this is a real thing. One thing is for certain though; whatever is the reason for conceding first and not performing well at the start of matches needs sorting.

Midfield

It was Paul Scholes and Darren Fletcher who lined up in the centre of midfield against QPR. Both had quiet games, not doing much wrong, but not greatly affecting the game. Fletcher’s defensive work, particularly in supporting the full-back, was of greater mobility than has been seen recently. Scholes was accurate in his passing, but failed to impact the game going forward. The introduction of Anderson added a drive to the midfield in a way that only Anderson can do, and was the antidote that worked against QPR. It would be harsh to blame the central midfield for all of United’s dullness however.

Yet again United’s wide players failed to inspire against the London side. Ashley Young had another tepid game, and Danny Welbeck looked even more unbalanced than usual out on the wings.  United wide players of the past (Ronaldo, Giggs, Beckham to name but a few) had a habit of producing that ultra-special moment that changed a tight game. Welbeck and Young looked nowhere near beating a man, let alone creating that special moment against QPR. The lack of confidence, swagger, and quality on United’s wings is an ongoing concern that only serves to limit United’s supply of creativity in matches.

Going Forward

The win and three points was the most important thing from this match. The performance was dull, but rarely in doubt apart from the few minutes QPR were ahead. United’s wing-play is concerning, and whilst the central midfield does little to inspire at times, the flexibility of options there is encouraging. With a busy December period now approaching, United will need to make full use of an excitingly big and varied squad as they look to reach the New Year in pole position.

Ratings

[4-4-2]: Lindegaard-6, Rafael-7, Ferdinand-7, Evans-7, Evra-6, Young-5, Fletcher-6, Scholes-6, Welbeck-6, Rooney-7, van Persie-6

(Anderson-8*, Hernandez-7, Powell-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Galatasaray 1 Manchester United 0

Champions League, Tuesday 20^th November 2012

A first defeat in the Champions League this season was of little consequence for an already-qualified Manchester United. The game was in fact a fairly even contest, but Galatasaray predictably had more intensity in their play, and they scored the only goal from a corner in the second-half. Below are some talking points from the match:

The other midfielders

Whilst Michael Carrick and Paul Scholes have been the stalwarts of the Manchester United midfield over the last year, this game against Galatasaray was an opportunity to view an amalgamation of United’s other options in that position. Lining-up in the diamond formation, Darren Fletcher, Tom Cleverley, Anderson, and Nick Powell all started.

Fletcher, by far the senior of the quartet, was at the base of the diamond as he continues on the comeback road to football after missing a large period of time due to his illness. He was neat, yet somewhat ineffective against the Turkish side. Nick Powell at the tip of the diamond, the youngest of the quartet, showed his mighty potential with his physical and technical ability, and came close for United when he struck the crossbar. The English youngster could have a fantastic career ahead of him. Cleverley was his usual efficient passing self, whilst Anderson offered less than usual in terms of attacking effectiveness, but had a solid game all round. These four midfielders all have claims to be in the first-team on a regular basis, and did no harm to their efforts against Galatasaray.

Phil Jones

Phil Jones played his first game since May against Galatasaray on his return from a lengthy injured spell, and was excellent. He looked sharp in the tackle, alert in positioning and the interception, and confident and calm on the ball. There has unsurprisingly been much talk about Jones’ long-term position, and it is an asset to such a young player than he offers the team something whether at right-back, midfield or centre-back. Against Galatasaray however he looked at home in his central defensive role. Naturally this appears to be his most-suited role, and time is on his side in terms of development. After all, the best central-defenders are never at their best until later in their careers. So welcome back to the team Phil Jones: (possibly) future Man United central-defensive gladiator.

Going Forward

It was somewhat bizarre for United to be involved in a game of so little consequence, and even more bizarre for there to be an air of content with a loss. But this game had positives in that the result didn’t matter, and the youthful players showed their potential. Teenagers Jones and Powell looked particularly promising, and it can be expected at least one of the midfield four will get a Premier League start very soon.

Ratings

[4-3-1-2]: Lindegaard-7, Rafael-5, Carrick-6, Jones-8*, Büttner-6, Fletcher-6, Anderson-6, Cleverley-7, Powell-6, Welbeck-8, Hernandez-6

(Young-6, Macheda-5, King-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Norwich City 1 Manchester United 0

Premier League, Saturday 17^th November 2012

United stumbled to a third defeat of the season at Carrow Road with a stuttering performance. Norwich took a second-half lead, but unlike on so many other occasions this season, the retorting onslaught from United never came, and they succumbed to a loss. Here’s some brief analysis:

Norwich blunten United’s attack

Sir Alex Ferguson’s side have not been short of goals this season, but at Carrow Road they drew a blank. Norwich City defended with superb organisation and prevented any clear United openings. Often with two banks of four behind the ball, Norwich offered no clear-cut opportunities for the Red Devils, who themselves failed to create any.

The Reds lacked any intensity in the game, and therefore made it easier for the Canaries to keep organised and concentrate. As is so often with United, the opposition has a much greater incentive and psychological drive to perform than the technically superior players in Red do. This showed at Carrow Road, as United simply failed to match the desire and drive shown by their counterparts. Had United moved the ball quicker and had a greater intensity to their game, it may have been that they dismantled the Norwich organisation. But as it was, Norwich defended well, and United created nought.

Wide players misfiring

United continued to suffer with average performances from their wingers against Norwich. On the left-side, Ashley Young once again showed his reluctance (or perhaps inability) to beat a man and was largely ineffective. The only threat from Young appeared to come late in the second-half when he moved right. Antonio Valencia was again also poor. The Ecuadorian gave little worry to the Norwich defence by offering a very limited direct threat. On the few occasions Valencia did actually cross a ball, the crosses themselves were woeful and gave the Red strikers little chance.

These wide-player performances against Norwich were certainly untimely. Norwich themselves are a narrow team with the potential for being exposed on the wings. Had United’s wingers been more potent and on their game, then perhaps this match may have seen a different result.

Going Forward

This game was a typical example of United failing to match the opposition intensity, and suffering the consequences. A disjointed team display didn’t break down an organised Norwich and paid the price. It can only be assumed that this will act as a motive in the coming games.

Ratings

[4-4-2]: Lindegaard-6, Rafael-7*, Smalling-7, Ferdinand-6, Evra-6, Valencia-5, Carrick-5, Giggs-6, Young-6, van Persie-5, Hernandez-6

(Scholes-6, Welbeck-6, Anderson-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Aston Villa 2 Manchester United 3

Premier League, Saturday 10^th November 2012

Javier Hernandez inspired Manchester United to yet another rousing comeback, as the Reds overturned a two-goal deficit at Villa Park. The Mexican scored a second-half hat-trick to ensure three points with a magnificent performance. Here’s some analysis on the game:

Vertical, not horizontal

As expected, United dominated possession, largely due to the passing duo of Michael Carrick and Paul Scholes in midfield. The downside of this partnership however, was frightfully obvious against the Villains. Scholes and Carrick play slowly, and horizontally across the pitch, meaning for all United’s dominance, a goal-scoring threat was nigh non-existent. The ageing Scholes and the slow Carrick were also exposed for Villa’s goals as they failed to react quick enough and tighten the midfield to stop counter-attacks from the opposition.

The introduction of Javier Hernandez at half-time was pivotal to the change in United’s fortunes. His tireless running in and around the Villa central defence unsettled the home side. Hernandez offered a constantly moving outlet, and created space for the United midfield to be more productive. The later introduction of Cleverley for Scholes also assisted in making the midfield more mobile. This enabled a more direct vertical threat, and also helped to secure a loose midfield.

Valencia’s woes

Antonio Valencia continued a poor patch of form with a lacklustre display against Aston Villa. His first-half was abysmal, and an improved second-half was only marginally better. The winger looks bereft of confidence and ideas. A reluctance to take on his man coupled with an inability to find a successful cross is worrying. Considering the 'average at best' Ashley Young, the out of form Nani, and the inbalance when Danny Welbeck plays wide, it is of paramount importance that Valencia regains his form. United's player of the season last term was on fire, and if he recaptures that confident menace he will be once again terrorizing left-backs.

Going Forward

Yet another comeback for United again affirmed the inherent belief within the side. David de Gea also had a commanding performance including a brilliant reaction save and several successful punching clearances. The continuing issue for United is slack defending, mainly due to a slow and inflexible midfield. United face a further two games away from home now as they look to build on a three game winning run.

Ratings

[4-4-2]: de Gea-8, Rafael-7, Smalling-7, Ferdinand-7, Evra-7, Valencia-5, Scholes-6, Carrick-6, Young-6, Rooney-6, van Persie-7

(Hernandez-9*, Cleverley-7, Anderson-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Braga 1 Manchester United 3

Premier League, Wednesday 7^th November 2012

This was a lazy performance from Manchester United largely due to questionable tactics and a lack of intensity. Braga took a second-half lead from the penalty spot, but after a bizarre delay due to floodlight failure United found some momentum to turn the game around. Strikers Robin van Persie, Wayne Rooney and Javier Hernandez all found the net to continue the Red’s good recent scoring run. Here are some thoughts from the game:

Tactics and substitutions

United lined up in a 4-1-4-1 formation with some unfamiliar personnel. Ryan Giggs played in the defensive midfield position, however at times was positionally exposed and unable to exert the same composure to the team as Michael Carrick or Darren Fletcher may have done. Anderson and Wayne Rooney played in front of him, but an ineffective first-half from Anderson coupled with a worryingly deep Rooney meant a lack of attacking threat. Nani and Danny Welbeck were also vastly ineffective on the wings and were appropriately substituted in the second half.

Second-half substitutions and a formation switch to 4-4-2 were the catalyst that enabled United to go on and win the match. Robin van Persie was introduced and formed a pairing up front with Hernandez, whilst Rooney moved left. Later in the half Rafael came on for Nani, and Valencia was moved further up the pitch on the wing. These fresh legs combined with the more attacking formation were the key to the victory. United simply looked lacklustre and uninventive with the original set-up.

The defence is coming together

Chris Smalling returned to the team for his first match since May, and is a welcome boost. He moved through this Braga match with relative ease as he looks to regain his match sharpness. Alongside him Jonny Evans had an uncharacteristically weak game, but came off with an injury and was substituted by the composed and controlled Ferdinand. The introduction of Rafael at right-back continued to prove the young Brazilian’s worth to the team as he added more security to the back line, whilst Patrice Evra also had another solid game.

Defensive injuries have been the curse of United’s squad this season, but now as Smalling returns, and Phil Jones returns to training, the United squad is looking stronger than ever.

Going Forward

This game was strange in many ways, not least the floodlight failure. United though will be pleased to have qualified with relative ease for the knockout stages, and to see injured players returning to the side. This was not a vintage performance, but the job was done, and the team can be satisfied. The future Champions League games are now an opportunity to give game time to those who need it, and to give experience to some young players.

Ratings

[4-1-4-1]: de Gea-7, Valencia-7, Smalling-6, Evans-5, Evra-6, Giggs-6, Nani-6, Anderson-5, Rooney-7*, Welbeck-5, Hernandez-7

(Ferdinand-7, van Persie-7, Rafael-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Manchester United 2 Arsenal 1

Premier League, Saturday 3^rd November 2012

A 2-1 scoreline fails to give justice to the ease with which Manchester United disposed of Arsenal in their first game of November. A largely comfortable performance was set on its way by an early Robin van Persie goal before Patrice Evra consolidated the lead in the second half. Arsenal’s goal with the last kick of the game was irrelevant to all but goal difference, and United should’ve in fact won by more. Here’s some analysis:

Defensive Shape

This fixture was certainly not the gargantuan battle of old, and United’s excellent defensive shape contributed to dismantling any Arsenal threat. Wayne Rooney was the epitome of discipline as he stuck to Mikel Arteta throughout the game, barely giving a Spaniard an inch to play in. By immediately stifling the heartbeat of Arsenal’s midfield, United had already won half the battle.

Behind Rooney, Tom Cleverley and Michael Carrick worked like beavers to prevent any creative threat from the inherently dangerous Santi Cazorla and Jack Wilshere. Whilst Carrick and Cleverley failed to offer their usual high standard of passing, their defensive positioning and work-rate was key to inhibiting Arsenal’s creativity. United’s back four was also on top form, with Evans in particular winning key duels high up the pitch. The one moment of weakness for United defensively was the sloppy manner in which they failed to clear the ball before conceding late on, but overall this was a disciplined and effective defensive performance that blunted Arsenal.

In-form players

Robin van Persie, Anderson, Wayne Rooney, Rafael and Jonny Evans can all stake a claim to be Manchester United’s most in-form player. It is van Persie and Anderson that particularly caught the eye against Arsenal however. The latter, coming on as a second-half substitute, showed the same spark and innovative quality that he worried Chelsea with in the week. As Sir Alex Ferguson commented, Anderson provided a ‘threat in behind’ the Arsenal midfield. The Brazilian certainly has an ability to inject verve and drive to a deep-lying centre midfield as he showed in this game.

Robin van Persie scored his 10^th goal of the season against Arsenal as he also demonstrated his immense value to this United side. His movement in the forward area was startlingly good and on several occasions this could have led to more goals had the offside flag not be raised, or in one particular move had he been aware of the time and space he had created for himself. His finishing ability, movement, and strength on the ball are all fantastic assets for United’s forward play, and they also provide a platform for Wayne Rooney to be at his dangerous best.

 

Going Forward

This game was positive in terms of the shape of the side and the ease of the victory. United were however at times sloppy in possession, and in particular the wide players offered little of their threatening potential. The Red Devils will get sterner tests than this Arsenal side, but no doubt will raise their game accordingly. For now though, for the first time this season, United sit pretty on the top of the league-a beautiful site.

Ratings

[4-4-1-1]: De Gea-7, Rafael-7, Ferdinand-7, Evans-8, Evra-7, Valencia-5, Carrick-6, Cleverley-6, Young-6, Rooney-7, van Persie-8*

(Anderson-8, Nani-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Chelsea 5 Manchester United 4

Capital One Cup, Wednesday 31^st October 2012

This was a gruelling defeat for a young United team. On the verge of a 3-2 victory after goals from Giggs, Hernandez and Nani, youngster Scott Wootton conceded a late penalty leading to an extra time period in which the Reds ultimately lost 5-4. United’s second-string side however looked purposeful and promising for the majority of the match, and the game will have undoubtedly given vital experience to the young players involved. Here are some talking points from the fixture:

Incumbents of 4-1-4-1

United’s second visit to Stamford Bridge in four days gave Sir Alex Ferguson the option to again choose the 4-1-4-1 formation, but this time with vastly different personnel. Darren Fletcher played in the defensive midfielder role, and provided security to the back four. At half-time however, Fletcher moved to right-back, and Chelsea brought on several quality attacking players. The combination of these two factors no doubt contributed to heavy pressure from the Blues after half-time, and United struggled. Fletcher’s role in midfield nevertheless reminded us of his usefulness to the team.

Ahead of Fletcher played Giggs and Anderson, both of whom arguably had their best performances of the season so far. Each player offers a direct running threat, and they both pressed high up the pitch to great effect. Anderson in particular demonstrated graft and guile, not only winning tackles and harrying the opposition, but also providing three assists and a general creative masterclass. Although composure in the form of Carrick, Cleverley or Scholes may have aided the team, the energy and fight shown by Fletcher, Giggs and Anderson was a contributing factor to the urgent pressing and counter-attacking ability shown by United for the most part against Chelsea. The 4-1-4-1 set-up once again proved its worth in getting at a stern opposition.

Next Generation

The average age of United’s starting 11 was merely 24, and at times it showed. U21 players Michael Keane, Scott Wootton, Nick Powell, Ryan Tunnicliffe and Federico Macheda all featured. Tunnicliffe and Macheda were granted little time to prove their qualities, both coming on as late substitutions. Nick Powell, a half-time substitute, was a joy to watch at times as he frequently demonstrated his superb first-touch ability and his willingness to run at goal. Defensively Powell also proved himself a useful physical presence when he tracked back twice to dispossess a Chelsea player.

The centre-back duo of Keane and Wootton had impressive games, but ultimately their shortcomings were the reasons behind Chelsea’s late goals. Both acquitted themselves superbly for the majority of the match and, despite some errors, must be praised for dealing with a Chelsea attack containing stellar names full of quality. Keane perhaps look more assured of the two defenders, and is the better bet for a long-term career at Old Trafford, but both showed their potential at in this game and will no doubt have successful careers, at United or elsewhere.

Going Forward

It is a disappointment that United will not be progressing further in this competition after coming so close. This performance however signalled three things; the depth of United’s squad, the talented youngsters coming through the ranks, and the continuing ability to score multiple goals against top opposition. It is bizarre to be talking so positively about a defeat, but United’s young team should be proud of their display against Chelsea and were unlucky not to progress. Let’s hope these players get the chance to continue showcasing their potential and ability.

Ratings

[4-1-4-1]: Lindegaard-7, Rafael-8, Keane-8, Wootton-6, Büttner-5, Fletcher-6, Nani-6, Anderson-9*,  Giggs-8,  Welbeck-6, Hernandez-7

(Powell-7, Tunnicliffe-6, Macheda-6)

*Man of the match

Analysis: Chelsea 2 Manchester United 3

Premier League, Sunday 28^th October 2012

High-scoring appears to be the name of the game for Manchester United this season, and this win against Chelsea was another intense, goal-filled encounter. United took an early lead thanks to an own goal and Robin van Persie, before the team in blue stormed back and levelled the game at 2-2. Two red cards later however, Chelsea were down to nine men, and United took full advantage as Hernandez scored the winner. Below is analysis on this fixture:

4-1-4-1

The 4-1-4-1 set-up chosen by Sir Alex Ferguson appeared the ideal counterbalance to Chelsea’s attacking threat. Michael Carrick sat in front of the defence with Wayne Rooney and Tom Cleverley in front of him acting as the midfield energy. Antonio Valencia played wide right with Robin van Persie up front. Ashley Young assumed a wide-left role, but also cut inside to great effect to support van Persie, a tactic that was instrumental in United’s first goal and Chelsea’s first red card.

The Reds focused their attacks down the right-hand side against a fragile Chelsea left, with Rafael and Valencia doubling up on Ashley Cole. With Ashley Young cutting inside, and Rooney surging forward, this meant an overload of players counter-attacking on the right, and Chelsea simply didn’t deal with it. The left-hand side of United was far more ineffective however, with Cleverley misfiring too many passes, and Young failing to threaten on that flank.

Carrick’s role in front of the defence paid dividends in the first half hour as he protected the back four whilst Rooney and Cleverley were busy putting out fires in front of him. As the match wore on however, United fell back failing to press high enough and invited pressure from Chelsea. Carrick’s effectiveness diminished, demonstrated by two particular occasions, one where he lost out physically in a key battle, and one where he should’ve been shutting down Eden Hazard rather than allowing Rooney to foul him for what led to the first Chelsea goal. Had United continued to be more effective in their midfield defensiveness then Chelsea may have been kept at bay.

Diving

On a weekend that saw many cards for diving, there were two in this match. Late on, Antonio Valencia received a yellow card for a soft tumble as he bypassed John Obi Mikel. Before that Fernando Torres was shown a yellow card for simulation, and was therefore sent off for multiple bookings. On both occasions free-kicks could’ve been undoubtedly been given due to the contact between defender and attacker. Nevertheless, on both occasions the offending diver clearly went down unnecessarily easily, and was certainly not brought down-it was the choice of the players that they fell to the ground.

On both occasions, the referee arguably made the correct decision. If football doesn’t mind simulation and play-acting, then certainly both situations should’ve resulted in free-kicks for the attacker. But if football wants to see an end to simulation and diving, then the referee made the right call. Cutting out pathetic tumbles is the first-step to stopping the endemic of diving. For his bravery, if anything, referee Mark Clattenburg should be praised.

Going Forward

United performed extremely well for the first 30 mins, and the 4-1-4-1 may become a useful formation away from home against strong opposition. For the most part the back four was solid, an encouragement. Rooney and van Persie once again showed their class, and Young got some vital competitive minutes as he continued his return from injury. United are now one point off Chelsea at the top of the league, and are on the charge. And as for the league itself, it will be very interesting to see whether diving really does get clamped down on, or whether this game was a mighty exception.

Ratings

[4-1-4-1]: De Gea-8, Rafael-8*, Ferdinand-8, Evans-6, Evra-8, Carrick-6, Valencia-6, Rooney-7, Cleverley-6, Young-6, , van Persie-8

(Hernandez-6, Giggs-6)

*Man of the match